Handgun comparison iconHandgun comparison icon

Springfield XD Full Size 4"vsSmith & Wesson Model 686 4"

Springfield XD Full Size 4" facing right

SpringfieldXD Full Size 4"

Striker-Fired Full-Sized Pistol Chambered in 9mm Luger, 40 S&W, 45 ACP
vs
Smith & Wesson Model 686 4" facing left

Smith & WessonModel 686 4"

DA/SA K/L-Frame Revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum

Dimensions

 LengthLHeightHWidthWWeightW
XD Full Size 4"7.3 in5.5 in1.2 in28 oz
Model 686 4"9.56 in6 in1.56 in40.3 oz

Details

 BarrelBBLTriggerWebsite
XD Full Size 4"4 inStriker-Firedspringfield-armory.com
Model 686 4"4.13 inDA/SAsmith-wesson.com

Notes

Springfield XD Full Size 4"

45ACP model is .25" taller. 40/45 model is 2 oz heaver than 9mm

Side-by-Side
Side-by-Side Comparison Charts

How do these two handguns stack up against eachother?

Tabletop
Tabletop Comparison

Drag/drop and reorder the handguns to compare on top of eachother