Handgun comparison icon Handgun comparison icon

Springfield XD 5" Tactical vs Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25"

Springfield XD 5" Tactical

Striker-Fired Full-Sized Pistol Chambered in 9mm Luger, 40 S&W, 45 ACP
vs

Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25"

DA/SA K/L-Frame Revolver Chambered in 357 Magnum

Dimensions

  Length L Height H Width W Weight W
XD 5" Tactical 8.3 in 5.5 in 1.2 in 31 oz
Model 19 Classic 4.25" 9.88 in 5.85 in 0 in 37.2 oz

Details

  Barrel BBL Trigger Website
XD 5" Tactical 5 in Striker-Fired springfield-armory.com
Model 19 Classic 4.25" 4.25 in DA/SA smith-wesson.com

Capacity

Notes

Springfield XD 5" Tactical

45ACP variant has is slightly taller at 5.75"

Smith & Wesson Model 19 Classic 4.25" is missing data required to properly compare side-by-side
  • Width
If you have any of this information, please send it to us. Read the Submission Guide to learn more.

Side-by-Side
Side-by-Side Comparison Charts

How do these two handguns stack up against eachother?

Tabletop
Tabletop Comparison

Drag/drop and reorder the handguns to compare on top of eachother